Writing

Who holds the receipt when the contract ends

The site supplies the resource. Someone else often leaves with the claim. Read that clause first.

Every project on a farm, in a plant or on a roof produces two things: a physical result and a set of receipts for it. The physical result stays at the site. The receipts go wherever the contract sends them. Operators negotiate hard over the first and often sign away the second without pricing it.

The digester

A dairy supplies manure and land. A developer builds the digester. One lender’s review of the sector notes that a dairy that fully owns and runs its own digester “is increasingly rare”, and that the gas itself “is typically the smallest share of the revenue stream”.[1] The larger share is the credits. In the common structure the developer holds them. The dairy is paid for manure.

That can be a fair trade. The developer carries the construction risk and the market risk. The point is that the dairy should know what the receipts were worth before agreeing to a manure price.

The roof

A manufacturer puts solar on its roof and, to help pay for it, sells the certificates. The power in the plant is physically from its own roof. Under US advertising rules, a company that generates renewable electricity but sells the certificates for all of it would be deceiving people if it said it uses renewable energy.[2] The customer who asks for a low-carbon product is then told, correctly, that the plant cannot claim one.

The water project

A food company funds an irrigation upgrade on a supplier’s farm and counts the water saved toward its own target. The method allows the claim only for the share that reflects the company’s contribution, and only while the project keeps working.[3] The farm did the work and lives in the basin. Whether the farm can also count that water, sell it to a second funder, or use it in its own certification depends on a sentence in the funding agreement that is often not there.

Four clauses to read

  1. Who owns each receipt today. Credits, certificates and any future instrument “arising from the project”.
  2. Who may make the claim. Ownership and the right to say it publicly are not always the same.
  3. What happens at the end of the term. Receipts for later years, and for instruments that do not exist yet.
  4. What happens if the rules change. A new programme, a new standard, a new unit.

The reason this matters more each year

New receipts keep being written. Hourly power certificates, water benefits and, soon, a measure for compute did not exist when many current contracts were signed. A clause that assigns “all environmental attributes” to a counterparty assigns things nobody has named yet. The site will still be producing them in ten years.

Sources

  1. Terrain (2025). Economic Sustainability of Dairy Digesters.
  2. US Federal Trade Commission. Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims, 16 CFR 260.15: Renewable energy claims.
  3. World Resources Institute (2025). Volumetric Water Benefit Accounting 2.0.