Writing

Unpaid on purpose

Much of the value an operation creates and is never paid for cannot be sold at all. Knowing which part can is the work.

It is easy to find value that nobody is paid for. The US Department of Energy estimates that “between 20 and 50% of industrial energy input is lost as waste heat”.[1] Farm digesters operate at about 400 US sites against more than 8,000 where they are technically feasible.[2] The temptation is to add all of this up and call it the opportunity.

Most of that sum is not for sale. Three rules remove it, and they are doing their job when they do.

Rule one: it has to be new

A buyer pays for a change, not for what already happens. One long-standing statement of the test says a project “is not additional and should not be eligible for stacking if that project would have gone forward without the combined incentive”.[3] A plant that already recovers its heat has nothing to sell for having done so. The value is real. The credit is not available.

Rule two: one claim per unit

The same tonne or megawatt-hour is counted once. A farmer whose practice is half paid for by a public grant has the carbon credits cut by half under one US protocol.[4] A plant that sells the certificates from its own solar array can no longer say it uses renewable power.[5] In both cases the second payment was never owed.

Rule three: the estimate is not the result

A field experiment on a large US home efficiency programme found that “the model-projected savings are roughly 2.5 times the actual savings”.[6] Value that exists only in the engineering model is not unpaid. It was never there.

What is left

After those three rules, the value that is truly orphaned is narrower and more useful to know about. It tends to sit in four places.

  • A second system nobody priced. The water saved by an energy project, or the heat from a water project.
  • A programme that does not ask about additionality. Fuel standards, certificates and tax credits pay on output, not on intent.
  • A customer who would pay and has not been asked. A supply-chain buyer with a target and no supplier data.
  • A decision made without the other rulebook open. A grant accepted before anyone checked what it does to the credit.

How we count it

Three columns for any site: what was created, what the rules bar, and what could be collected. The first column is always the largest and the least interesting. The third is the only one that is a business case.

Sources

  1. US Department of Energy. Waste Heat Recovery Basics.
  2. US Environmental Protection Agency (2026). AgSTAR Data and Trends.
  3. World Resources Institute (2009). Stacking Payments for Ecosystem Services.
  4. Climate Action Reserve (2021). Nitrogen Management Project Protocol, version 2.1.
  5. US Federal Trade Commission. Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims, 16 CFR 260.15: Renewable energy claims.
  6. Fowlie, Greenstone and Wolfram (2015). Do Energy Efficiency Investments Deliver? Evidence from the Weatherization Assistance Program. NBER Working Paper 21331.