Time means three different things
Every receipt has a date on it. On a carbon credit, an energy certificate and a water benefit, the date is answering three different questions.
“Time” is the fourth line on every receipt and the one most often misread. The word is the same on each. The question behind it is not.
Carbon asks: how long does it last?
A tonne of carbon removed is a stock. The claim is that it stays out of the air. One North American registry puts it this way: “For high quality offsets, permanence is defined as at least 100 years of GHG reduction or sequestration.”[1] So a carbon receipt carries two times: the year the tonne was counted, and the length of the promise. A tonne stored in soil and a tonne stored in rock can share a year and a unit and still be different products.
Energy asks: was it at the same moment?
A megawatt-hour is a flow. It is made and used in the same instant, so the question is whether the certificate and the use line up. For years the answer was “in the same year”. That let a company run at night on gas and claim midday solar. A 2022 study found that the use of such certificates “has led to an inflated estimate of the effectiveness of mitigation efforts”.[2]
The rules are moving to the hour. The newest certificate standard covers “a period of one hour or less”.[3] The main accounting standard has proposed counting certificates only if they are “matched to hourly electricity consumption (hourly matching)” and delivered on the same grid.[4] It is not final. A power contract signed now should be tested against both versions.
Water asks: is it still happening?
A water benefit is also a flow, measured per year, and it has to be earned again each year. The leading method allows a company to keep claiming a volume only while “the implementation activities are functioning as designed”.[5] If the irrigation upgrade is abandoned or the wetland silts up, the claim stops. A ten-year total quoted as one number hides that.
What goes wrong
Three mistakes follow from reading one clock as another.
- Treating a flow as a stock. Adding up ten years of water benefit and presenting it like ten thousand stored tonnes.
- Treating a stock as a flow. Selling a tonne stored for twenty years as though it were the same as one stored for a thousand.
- Matching the wrong window. Buying a year of certificates for a load that runs by the hour.
What we check
For any receipt, three things under “time”: the period it was earned in, the period it has to last, and what happens to the claim if it stops. If the seller can answer only the first, the receipt is incomplete.
Sources
- Climate Action Reserve (2022). Keeping it 100: permanence in carbon offset programs.
- Bjørn and others (2022). Renewable energy certificates threaten the integrity of corporate science-based targets. Nature Climate Change.
- EnergyTag (2024). Granular Certificate Scheme Standard, version 2.
- GHG Protocol (2026). Scope 2 market-based method update: 2025-2026 public consultation and current status.
- World Resources Institute (2025). Volumetric Water Benefit Accounting 2.0.