The specialist is paid on the instrument
The person selling you a project is usually expert in one instrument and paid on it. Ask three questions before you sign.
A carbon developer earns when credits are issued. A solar developer earns when megawatts are built. Each is good at its own instrument. Neither is paid to tell you that something else at your site is worth more.
The dairy digester business shows where that leads. A dairy that fully owns and runs its own digester is now “increasingly rare”.[1] More often a developer owns the plant, pays the dairy for manure, and keeps the credits. The dairy supplies the feedstock and the site. The developer holds the receipts.
That can be the right deal. Running a gas plant is not dairy farming. But the same review records what the models assumed: “Many projects began when LCFS credit values were near $200, based on assumptions that the value would remain in that range for several years.”[1] When the price of that one California fuel credit fell, the projects “became much less of a homerun”.
A model built by the seller of one instrument leans on that instrument.
Three questions for any proposal
- What happens if this price halves? If the answer is that the project fails, you are being sold a position in a credit market.
- What else moves at the site? Water, heat, emissions, the power bill. If the proposal names only one, the rest has not been looked at.
- Who holds each receipt when the contract ends? The credits, the certificates and the right to make the claim.
We work for the operator. The questions above are where we start.
Sources
- Terrain (2025). Economic Sustainability of Dairy Digesters.