Four receipts, four stages
Energy, carbon, water and compute are all on the way to being counted, compared and paid for. They are not equally far along.
A resource becomes a market when two strangers can agree on what was delivered. That takes a receipt: a claim, a unit, an issuer and a time. Four systems we work in are at four different points on that road.
Energy: written, and being rewritten
The megawatt-hour certificate is the oldest of the four. The unit is settled and issuers are established. What is changing is time. The newest standard defines a certificate for “energy produced during a period of one hour or less”.[1] The main corporate accounting rules are being revised in the same direction, with a combined consultation “slated for Q2 2027” and the new standard “slated for publication in Q4 2028”.[2] Anyone signing a long power contract today is signing across that change.
Carbon: written, and contested
The tonne has registries, methods and verifiers. It also has a credibility problem that the receipt does not show. One study of about a fifth of all credits issued estimated that “less than 16% of the carbon credits issued to the investigated projects constitute real emission reductions”.[3] The unit was a tonne every time. What failed was the baseline, which is in the small print.
Water: half written
The most used method for corporate water claims describes itself as “voluntary, principle-based, and nonprescriptive guidance”.[4] It tells a company how to count a volume. It does not issue anything. The company makes the claim itself. Beside it sits a true certificate, issued by one foundation, where each one “restores 1,000 gallons to a freshwater source in need”.[5] So water has a method without an issuer and an issuer without a market of rivals. A basin is also not interchangeable with another basin, which no unit can fix.
Compute: not yet written
Compute is sold by the hour of a named chip. That is a unit of time on a machine. It is not a unit of work done. One consultancy that favours the market concedes that “the same GPU on the same day can fetch significantly different prices across indices”.[6] An exchange has announced futures that it says “will now turn compute into a standardized, tradable commodity”, with a launch date given as “pending regulatory review”.[7] A future needs an index, an index needs comparable trades, and comparable trades need an agreed measure of what was delivered. That measure is the missing receipt.
Why the order matters
Each stage has its own kind of work and its own kind of mistake.
- Where the receipt is mature, value comes from reading the rule change early.
- Where it is contested, value comes from evidence good enough to survive a sceptical buyer.
- Where it is half written, value comes from choosing which method to stand on.
- Where it is not written, value comes from helping to write it.
The common error is to carry habits from one stage into another: to treat a water volume like a traded tonne, or a chip-hour like a megawatt-hour. They look alike on a slide. They are years apart.
Sources
- EnergyTag (2024). Granular Certificate Scheme Standard, version 2.
- GHG Protocol (2026). Scope 2 market-based method update: 2025-2026 public consultation and current status.
- Probst and others (2024). Systematic assessment of the achieved emission reductions of carbon crediting projects. Nature Communications.
- World Resources Institute (2025). Volumetric Water Benefit Accounting 2.0.
- Bonneville Environmental Foundation. Water Restoration Certificates: frequently asked questions.
- Boston Consulting Group (2026). The New Economics of AI Compute Markets.
- CME Group (2026). CME Group and Silicon Data to Launch Compute Futures on October 5.